diff --git a/reviews/a-review-2026-05-25.md b/reviews/a-review-2026-05-25.md
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..84ebdd3
--- /dev/null
+++ b/reviews/a-review-2026-05-25.md
@@ -0,0 +1,37 @@
+# a-review — 2026-05-25
+
+**Model:** gemini
+**Diff base:** `HEAD~1` (5 files changed, 615 insertions(+), 30 deletions(-))
+**Session reference:** none
+**Context:** CLAUDE.md + session notes + expanded diff
+
+---
+
+Excellent work. The changes are well-structured, follow existing project conventions, and include a comprehensive test suite. This is a high-quality contribution. I have only one minor finding and one informational note.
+
+### [WARNING] Logic Error
+
+*   **File:** `src/second_brain/web/templates/source_detail.html`
+*   **Location:** Line 151
+*   **Issue:** The "Re-extract only" button is conditionally rendered with `{% if source.has_transcript and source.source_type == 'video' %}`. This is too restrictive. The backend service function `reset_source_for_retry` correctly allows an "extract" retry for any source that has content in `transcript_text`, which includes processed articles. Limiting this feature to only videos in the UI prevents a valid and useful action for non-video sources.
+*   **Suggestion:** Change the conditional to `{% if source.has_transcript %}`. This will correctly show the button for any source (article or video) that has been pulled and has content ready for extraction, which matches the backend's capability.
+
+```html
+    <!-- Change this -->
+    {% if source.has_transcript and source.source_type == 'video' %}
+    
+    <!-- To this -->
+    {% if source.has_transcript %}
+```
+
+### [INFO] Security
+
+*   **Files:** `src/second_brain/web/app.py`, `src/second_brain/web/templates/source_detail.html`
+*   **Observation:** The changes introduce new endpoints (`/edit`, `/retry`) that modify database state. According to `CLAUDE.md`, the application has "No auth" and relies on being deployed in a trusted, LAN-only environment. These new endpoints increase the number of ways an unauthorized user on the network could alter data.
+*   **Context:** This is not a new vulnerability, but an expansion of the existing trust model. As long as the application remains on a trusted network, this is acceptable per the project's documented security posture. It's worth keeping in mind that no CSRF protection is being used for these HTMX `POST` actions.
+
+### Summary
+
+The overall code quality is very high. The changes are thoughtfully implemented, with a clean separation between the CLI, the web layer, and a shared service layer. The refactoring in `web/app.py` to create `_render_source_detail` is a good move for maintainability. The addition of a thorough, live-DB test suite for the new service functions is commendable and demonstrates a commitment to quality.
+
+Once the minor template logic issue is resolved, this change will be in perfect shape.
diff --git a/src/second_brain/web/templates/source_detail.html b/src/second_brain/web/templates/source_detail.html
index fa6cf59..0af4dae 100644
--- a/src/second_brain/web/templates/source_detail.html
+++ b/src/second_brain/web/templates/source_detail.html
@@ -144,13 +144,15 @@
         Re-run from scratch
     </button>
 
-    {% if source.has_transcript and source.source_type == 'video' %}
-    <!-- Light retry: skip the re-download/re-transcribe, just re-extract. -->
+    {% if source.has_transcript %}
+    <!-- Light retry: skip the re-pull, just re-run LLM extraction. Works
+         for any source with stored body text (videos have transcripts,
+         articles have the trafilatura-extracted body). -->
     <button hx-post="/sources/{{ source.id }}/retry"
             hx-vals='{"mode": "extract"}'
             hx-target="body"
             hx-swap="innerHTML"
-            hx-confirm="Re-extract only — keep the existing transcript and re-run the LLM extraction?"
+            hx-confirm="Re-extract only — keep the existing transcript/body and re-run the LLM extraction?"
             class="px-5 py-2 bg-amber-100 text-amber-800 text-sm font-semibold rounded hover:bg-amber-200 border border-amber-300 transition-colors">
         Re-extract only
     </button>